Snap hooks and carabiners (also called carbine hooks) are both mainstay quick-release shackles for the industrial sector.  They don’t even look all that different, in some cases. So what’s the difference? Actually, there are numerous—and significant—differences in how they’re used.

A Quick-Release Shackle Comparison:

As stainless steel hardware, both designs are capable of being load-rated for incredible maximum loads. However, carabiners tend to have an edge. Both designs are far simpler to release than traditional shackles with threaded bolts, but snap hooks are the most agile for emergency release. 

Here’s the skim:

These differences in performance lead to a corresponding variance in the uses of each quick-release shackle type. But some nuances may give you enough pause to reconsider your choice. 

For instance, a snap hook is the better choice if you must have the ability to disconnect while the load is under tension. But for the same reason, it’s theoretically possible for a snap hook to accidentally release and drop the load. A carabiner is not capable of releasing a tensioned load—unless load variance (i.e., bouncing) occasionally eliminates tension or the carabiner itself is overloaded and fails. 

A snap hook can also be released with nothing but one finger and a pull of the plunger.  However, you’ll have to navigate your finger through the ring to do it. Carabiners are simpler (a squeeze opens it), but a threaded locking sleeve would require some manipulation to unfasten. As one solid loop, it’s also possible for carabiners to accidentally reverse orientation (a snap shackle has two separate loops, so it’s more stable).

You’ll have to weigh the pros and cons for your application. Many quick-release shackles will have additional features to mitigate the shortcomings in the design and further augment the strengths. 

For example, here are two industrial-grade quick-release shackles from Ronstan:

Ronstan RF650 Threaded-Lock Carabiner

• Ferrule Lined Closed Eye: Maintain carabiner orientation while containing and protecting the fixed line from wear and tear.  No accidental release, no seam, no pinching, no problem.
• Sprung Closing Mechanism: Long-lasting spring firmly secures the contained rope, wire, or loop.
• Optional Locking Sleeve: Choose from models with threaded locking sleeves or non-locking models, depending on preference for added security or ease-of-use.
• Removable Thimble: To prevent tangling or accidental removal of the hook from the lanyard.
• Easy Single-Handed Operation: Latch onto a rope, belt, or cable with your free hand while your other hand continues to operate heavy equipment.
• All-Stainless Steel Design: For extreme durability, no corrosion, and continued use in the harshest environments with little maintenance.

Ronstan RF 6100 Fixed Bail Snap Shackle

• Heavy-Duty Plunger: Precise component and spring assembly will ensure dependable service. The split ring is spot welded to prevent accidental dismantling.
• Streamlined Body: Bail (non-opening loop) and trunnion (opening hook) are smoothly shaped to clear lines and attachment points easily when open.
• Ultra-High Strength: Exceptional breaking load of 4,840 lbs on a small, light fitting.
• Two Finishes: Available in a polished finish or black oxide.
• All-Stainless Steel Design: For extreme durability, no corrosion, and continued use in the harshest environments with little maintenance.

Ronstan Industrial’s snap shackles and carbine hooks are all made with the finest materials and are battle-tested in applications on the open ocean. While not intended for human suspension, our products are ideal for fast attachment of tool lanyards or securing of appropriate equipment.  They’re also ergonomically designed for simple operation without any tangling or snags while you work. 

Need a manufacturer with quick-release shackles you can count on? Get in touch today.